My judgement is based on following grounds:

Volkswagen Polo
The VW Polo raises the sub-compact standard to unusual heights. In terms of driving comfort, extra equipment and finish it has almost reached a higher vehicle category. An extra point is given for the BlueMotion model so consequently trimmed towards fuel economy.

Opel Astra
The Opel Astra looks good and is well produced. Mainly the suspension and many affordable innovations are convincing. With regards to fuel economy and modern gearboxes, however, Opel needs to step up.

Toyota iQ
Many clever ideas are packed into the Toyota iQ, and praised be the courage to present a new car concept with a three and a half seater. However, the engines should be more economical and materials chosen for the interior don’t live up to the high purchasing price.

Skoda Yeti
The Skoda Yeti is a compelling family estate but also a convincing offroader. Its close technical relationship with the VW Tiguan costs the Yeti some points. Nevertheless it has an independent and likeable appearance and will certainly be a successful offer.

Peugeot 3008
The Peugeot 3008 seems to want too much at the same time. Some imagination is needed to take it seriously as an estate, van and SUV all at once. It is a pity that the Diesel hybrid will only be launched in 2011.