My judgement is based on following grounds:

Opel Insignia
Heavy and probably too big for both the current climate and a target of 10 points, the Opel Insignia has to be rewarded for a few remarkable innovations like its very efficient headlights and road signs reading systems. The range is extensive: engines ranging from 1.6 to 2.8 V6 turbo with three good Diesels, front or all wheel drive, 5 doors, sedan and break. The first tests have shown a high level of handling and comfort, thanks to the active damping. I think that the Insignia demonstrates a real effort on Opel’s part that must be recognised.

Ford Fiesta
Lighter than the model it replaces, the new Fiesta shows that Ford is heading in the right direction, but the Mazda2 launched last year was still better in this field. Anyway, the Fiesta is very interesting for handling, comfort and urban capability. Just like the previous one.

Volkswagen Golf
Same player shoots again? It seems so, but the Golf VI really is better than previous one. With TSi engine, DSG transmission, active damping and a high level of quality, there’s a very consistent car here.

Citroën C5
What a beautiful car! For sure, the prettiest Citroen for a very long time. But, like the insignia, the C5 is also a very heavy car. At least 130kg more than the previous C5. Compared to that one, the new car doesn’t represent real technical evolution. Same engines, same transmission, same suspension; I do not think evolution is important enought for the C5 to challenge the Opel for the first place.

Renault Mégane
Based on the same platform, the new Megane corrects the defects of the previous one – namely poor handling due to its power steering and an unpractical trunk. Still, the Megane 2008 is not innovative enough. And compared to the Golf, quality and engine availabillity are not at the same level.

Alfa Romeo Mito
Nice, but just a marketing car. Its handling and comfort levels are disappointing.

Skoda Superb
The twin door will probably not bring about a revolution. Nevertheless, value for money is its best quality.